New Blog Post featured image for FTC ban on non-competes for commercial law clients in the United States

FTC Bans Non-Competes: What Employers
and Employees Need to Know

On April 23, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issued a groundbreaking final rule prohibiting all non-compete agreements for employees at all levels, with only extremely limited exceptions. This significant change is set to reshape the landscape of employment contracts and labor mobility in the United States. As commercial litigation attorneys, The Downs Law Group aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of this new rule, its implications for both employees and employers, and the potential legal challenges that may arise.

Understanding the New FTC Rule

The FTC’s final rule broadly bans all non-compete clauses, defining them as:

“[a] term or condition of employment that prohibits a worker from, penalizes a worker for, or functions to prevent a worker from either seeking or accepting work after the conclusion of employment, or operating a business after the conclusion of employment.”

This definition is intentionally broad, ensuring that non-compete clauses cannot be disguised as other types of contractual terms or workplace policies.

Positive Impacts on Employee Rights

From an employee rights standpoint, this new rule is a significant win. Employees will no longer be restricted by non-compete clauses that prevent them from working in their chosen field, in the same geographic area, or for a specified period of time after leaving a job. This change opens up numerous opportunities for workers, allowing them greater freedom to pursue their careers without limitations imposed by former employers. Employees can now:

  • Seek Better Positions: Move freely to new positions within their industry without fearing legal repercussions.
  • Negotiate Better Terms: Leverage their skills and experience to negotiate better employment terms without the constraint of a non-compete.
  • Increase Market Competition: Foster a more competitive job market where talent can move freely, potentially leading to innovation and growth.

Potential Negative Impacts and Challenges for Employers

While the rule is beneficial for employees, it does present several challenges and potential drawbacks for employers. These include:

  1. Impact on Employee Compensation: Non-compete clauses are often included in employment contracts in exchange for additional consideration, such as higher salaries or bonuses. With the elimination of these clauses, employers may be less inclined to offer such financial incentives, potentially leading to a decrease in overall employee compensation.
  2. Reduced Investment in Employee Training: Employers may become hesitant to invest heavily in employee training and education if they fear that employees can leave at any time and use that training to benefit a competitor. This could result in reduced opportunities for professional development within companies.
  3. Increased Trade Secret Disputes: The prohibition of non-compete agreements may lead to an uptick in trade secret litigation. Employers might attempt to use trade secret protections as an alternative means to restrict former employees from joining competitors. This could complicate the legal landscape, as courts will need to carefully balance the protection of trade secrets with the new regulations prohibiting non-compete clauses.

Legal Considerations and Litigation Risks

The new rule’s broad definition of non-compete clauses includes any term or condition that “functions to prevent” a worker from competing. This could potentially encompass non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), training repayment agreement provisions (TRAPs), and overbroad non-solicitation agreements if they effectively prevent an employee from seeking or accepting other work or starting a new business after their employment ends.

What Employers Should Consider:

  • Reviewing and Revising Contracts: Employers should scrutinize their current employment agreements to ensure compliance with the new FTC rule. Any terms that could be construed as non-compete clauses should be revised or eliminated.
  • Consulting Legal Counsel: Given the complexity of the new rule and its potential implications, employers should seek legal advice to navigate the changes effectively and avoid potential litigation.
  • Adjusting Business Strategies: Companies may need to rethink their strategies for protecting proprietary information and retaining top talent without relying on non-compete clauses.

Future of Trade Secret Law

As non-compete clauses become illegal, the enforcement of trade secrets is likely to adapt. Employers may increasingly rely on trade secret laws to prevent employees from joining competitors, claiming that such moves would inevitably lead to the disclosure of confidential information. This could lead to more litigation and necessitate clearer legal standards for what constitutes a trade secret and how it can be protected without infringing on the new rule’s intent.

Key Points for Employers and Employees:

  • Stay Informed: Both employers and employees should stay informed about the latest developments in trade secret law and how they may interact with the new FTC rule.
  • Clear Agreements: Employers should ensure that NDAs and other agreements are clearly defined and narrowly tailored to protect legitimate business interests without violating the new rule.
  • Legal Recourse: Employees should be aware of their rights and the legal recourse available to them if they believe an employer is improperly using trade secret claims to restrict their employment opportunities.

Conclusion

The FTC’s final rule banning non-compete agreements represents a significant shift in employment law, aimed at enhancing worker mobility and fostering a more competitive job market. While it offers substantial benefits for employees, it also presents new challenges for employers in terms of compensation strategies, employee training, and protecting proprietary information.

For employers, adapting to these changes will require a careful review of existing agreements, consultation with legal experts, and potentially new strategies for retaining talent and safeguarding trade secrets. Employees, on the other hand, will need to understand their new rights and remain vigilant against any attempts to circumvent the spirit of the new rule.

If you have any questions about how this rule affects your business or need assistance with compliance, our team of experienced commercial litigation attorneys is here to help. Contact The Downs Law Group today to ensure you are prepared for significant changes in employment law.